Critical Reception of The Super Mario Galaxy Movie
The release of the new Super Mario Bros. Movie has sparked a wave of critical responses, many of which are less than enthusiastic. While the first film in the series received mixed reviews, it managed to achieve massive commercial success, becoming one of the top-grossing films of all time. Now, as anticipation builds for the sequel, critics have been vocal about their opinions, with some offering particularly harsh assessments.
Notable Reviews and Reactions
The Guardian (1/5)
The Guardian’s review highlights the film’s visual dullness, describing it as a “visually dull screensaver of a movie.” The reviewer also criticizes the lack of humor, noting that the film fails to deliver engaging dialogue or memorable moments.
The Times (0/5)
This scathing review calls the film “a supremely vacuous anti-movie,” comparing its climax to a sequence featuring full-screen Nintendo gameplay. The reviewer claims the experience was so unpleasant that they had to use physical methods to distract themselves from the distress caused by the film.
The Telegraph (2/5)
Despite being a negative review, this one acknowledges that the sequel is an improvement over the original. However, it still falls short of being a quality film, with the reviewer calling it “absolute rubbish.”
Variety
Variety describes the film as “frenetic in such an impersonal way” that it feels like it needs medication. The review suggests that the film prioritizes fan service over storytelling, resulting in a shallow narrative.
Empire (2/5)
Empire’s review notes that while the film offers some nostalgic moments for adults, it is otherwise “humourless” and “hysterical.” The reviewer points out that the film lacks any real purpose beyond catering to fans.
The Hollywood Reporter
This review praises the film’s fast-paced nature and hyperkinetic visuals, suggesting that it caters well to its target audience. However, it acknowledges that adult viewers may find little interest beyond the vocal cast.
The Independent (2/5)
The Independent criticizes the film for its blandness, noting the lack of plot, memorable characters, and even a unique song from Jack Black. The reviewer also mentions that the only real joke in the film is a recycled one from Disney’s Zootopia.
TheWrap
TheWrap’s review compares the film to a boat that never rocks, suggesting that it lacks the excitement and challenge found in the games it is based on. The reviewer argues that the film is more of a reminder of the franchise’s existence than a meaningful adaptation.
IndieWire (C-)
While acknowledging the game’s brilliance, IndieWire’s review states that the film fails to capture the same level of joy and creativity. It describes the film as “flat” and overly corporate.
Radio Times (2/5)
Radio Times notes that while the film may not offer much new for retro gamers, it should be enjoyable for children. This could be a relief for parents looking for entertainment during the Easter holidays.
RogerEbert.com (1.5/4)
This review suggests that the film is more of a respite for parents than a cinematic experience. It is described as “cute, breezy, and rock-stupid,” with the potential to make another billion dollars.
Forbes
Forbes highlights the film’s energetic pace and abundance of gaming references, calling it a “manic roller coaster ride.” The reviewer notes that the increased number of power-ups adds fun and interesting combat elements for Mario and Luigi.
Conclusion
As The Super Mario Galaxy Movie prepares for its theatrical release, the critical reception has been varied. While some reviewers acknowledge minor improvements over the original, many express disappointment with the film’s lack of depth and creativity. The film seems to cater primarily to younger audiences and fans of the franchise, with limited appeal for broader demographics.
