Essendon Fans Face Criticism for Treatment of Defender Ben McKay
Essendon fans have come under scrutiny for their vocal criticism of defender Ben McKay during the team’s significant loss to Brisbane on Saturday afternoon. The incident has sparked a broader conversation about fan behavior and the impact it can have on players.
McKay, who had a game-low five disposals and took just two marks in the defeat, found himself at the center of the crowd’s attention. Every time he touched the ball, fans from the stands jeered and heckled him. This behavior did not go unnoticed by commentators and former players, many of whom expressed concern over the tone of the support.
During the fourth quarter, McKay managed to intercept a Lachie Neale kick near the goal square. This moment, however, was met with one of the loudest bronx cheers of the day, which left some broadcasters questioning the intent behind the fan reactions.
Former West Coast coach Adam Simpson, commenting on Fox Footy, noted, “I’m not sure if that was a positive cheer.” He added, “Bit of a whipping boy today. He hasn’t done a lot wrong. Just hasn’t done a lot.”
St Kilda great Leigh Montagna echoed similar sentiments, stating, “He’s only had the four disposals, but that’s not his role.” The criticism extended beyond the field, with Liam Pickering, an AFL player manager and former Geelong star, expressing disappointment in the behavior of Essendon fans.
“Listen to that. It’s actually cruel, that, to be honest,” Pickering told SEN. Gerard Whateley, a leading AFL commentator sitting next to Pickering, agreed, saying, “Essendon fans should have a real think about whether they want to do that.”
A leaked whiteboard from Brisbane’s training facility labeled McKay’s weakness as “low confidence” on Friday. Whether this was due to form issues or the jeering from the stands, the defender spent a large portion of the third quarter on the bench.
Ben McKay’s brother, Harry, who plays for Carlton, sat out part of the 2025 season as he battled mental health challenges. At the time, Ben expressed pride in his brother for taking the situation seriously.
The 28-year-old joined Essendon as a free agent for the 2024 season from North Melbourne and was reportedly paid up to $1.5 million in his first season, with a deal worth as much as $6 million. He has played 112 AFL games, 41 of them for the Bombers.
This is not the first time Essendon fans have faced criticism for their treatment of players. In 2011, fans were called out for booing and jeering midfielder Brent Stanton during a game against West Coast. Stanton was substituted out with an injury, and then-Essendon coach Mark Thompson commented on the situation, saying, “It’s just amazing really that our supporters can do that.”
Stanton currently works at the Bombers as an assistant coach.
If you or anyone you know needs immediate support, contact Lifeline on 13 11 14 or via lifeline.org.au. In an emergency, call 000.
