State of Origin Coaching Conundrum: Scott Dismisses Conflict of Interest Fears
The upcoming State of Origin clash is more than just a showcase of AFL talent; it’s also a breeding ground for interesting discussions off the field. Geelong Cats coach Chris Scott, set to lead the Victorian side, has playfully dismissed concerns raised by former Port Adelaide coach Ken Hinkley regarding potential conflicts of interest for coaches involved in the representative game. Hinkley had voiced apprehension that coaches might leverage their temporary roles to poach AFL stars for their respective clubs.
Scott, however, offered a light-hearted rebuttal, suggesting his presence in the Victorian camp might actually deter players from joining the Cats. “If anything, me being there might put players off joining Geelong,” Scott quipped. “You never know.”
The AFL’s decision to revive the State of Origin with a blockbuster match at Optus Stadium on Saturday pits Victoria against Western Australia. While Scott takes the reins for the Big V, Sydney Swans coach Dean Cox will be at the helm for the Sandgropers.
Hinkley, who recently stepped down after a successful 13-year tenure at Port Adelaide, had specifically highlighted the risk of coaches using the State of Origin platform for recruitment. He pointed to the situation of Port Adelaide’s star midfielder Zak Butters, whose contract is up for renewal this year, making him a prime target for several Victorian clubs, including the likes of Hawthorn and Geelong.
Western Australia’s coach, Dean Cox, was unequivocal when questioned about any potential recruitment activities during his time with the WA squad. “My greater purpose is to get these players to perform well for WA,” Cox stated firmly. “It’s not about recruiting. And I think what you’ll find is most of these players are on long-term deals, because they deserve it.” His sentiment underscores the primary objective of the State of Origin: to celebrate and honour the talent from each state.
Scott Addresses Leave Rumours
Beyond the State of Origin spotlight, Scott also addressed speculation surrounding his own commitment to the Geelong Football Club. Reports had circulated that he had taken an extended period of leave from his coaching duties this season.
The 49-year-old, who has been a consistent presence at the helm of the Cats since 2011, neither confirmed nor denied the rumours of an extended break. However, he alluded to the possibility, suggesting it would be a perfectly reasonable step for a coach with his extensive tenure. Scott reminisced about conversations with former Geelong president Colin Carter, who, drawing from his experience at Boston Consulting Group (BCG), had long advocated for the benefits of sabbaticals.
“I first met (former Geelong president) Colin Carter when I got to Geelong 15 years ago,” Scott explained. “So through his experience at BCG (Boston Consulting Group), I reckon from year three he talked to me about the idea of a sabbatical.” He elaborated on the BCG model, where employees are often encouraged to take time away from work periodically. “I think at BCG, every seven years they insist on their people taking a period of time away from work, and he espoused the virtues of that for a long time.”
While he stopped short of confirming he had taken such a break, Scott acknowledged the concept. “That’s not necessarily what I have done, but it’s something that we’ve spoken about, and I don’t think it’s a radical idea for people who have been around for a long time.” He also sought to clarify any misconceptions arising from his absence from public view. “The second point I’d make is (just) because you don’t see me at an open training session, you shouldn’t extrapolate that to ‘I’m not there at all’.” This suggests a strategic approach to his involvement, even if not always visible to the public eye.
Victoria Boasts an Unprecedented Lineup
The Victorian team assembled for the State of Origin is, by all accounts, a formidable force. The midfield alone reads like a who’s who of the AFL’s elite. Captain Marcus Bontempelli will be joined by a host of game-changers, including Bailey Smith, Caleb Serong, Matt Rowell, Nick Daicos, Zach Merrett, Zak Butters, and Noah Anderson, among others.
The depth of talent extends to the forward and defensive lines, creating what Scott believes is the greatest team ever put together for such an occasion. “I’ve got a bit of recency bias,” Scott admitted, acknowledging his immediate appreciation for the current squad. “I mean, I did watch some of the great State Games with (Gary) Ablett and (Jason) Dunstall and (Tony) Lockett all playing the same team.”
However, after careful consideration, he concluded, “This is the best team that I’ve ever seen take the field.” This high praise sets the stage for an enthralling contest, with Victoria aiming to live up to the immense expectations placed upon them by their star-studded lineup and their confident coach.
